Locke, your habit of deep discussion is frightening even to me.
I could probably write a ten page thesis on this subject without taking a breath, but I'll try to keep it short enough to be understandable. Keep in mind, this is merely my own opinions in most cases, backed up by the odd fact here and there, and what I've observed or experienced.
Before beginning to answer the question "Does magic exist," we have the need to define the term "magic." For the purposes of this discussion, I suppose "Magic" would be defined as "any occurance that cannot be explained by human scientific knowledge of the way things behave in the natural or physical realm of existence." I just came up with that off the top of my head, so if it doesn't quite do the job, then we can revise it later.
If we do define "magic" as we have done above, then the answer to the question of whether it exists, is most definately
yes, magic does in fact exist. I don't think anyone would deny the fact that there certainly are rather frequent occurances, or at least reports of frequent occurances of things that cannot be explained. However, that does not do us much good in explaining
what magic is.
For that, we must do much more research, and explore many more possibilities and occurances throughout the history of man and our philosophies concerning the metaphysical.
Since the beginning of the history of Man, we have struggled with the question of "What else is there?" Is there a spiritual realm? And if so, is the spiritual realm a reflection of the natural world or is the natural world but a shadow of a true existence in the spiritual realm. (See the works of Plato and Aristotle for discussions at great exhaustive lengths on the subject).
It is at this very early point in the discussion that most people find disagreement. Though the question has been debated for millenia, we have yet to find a solution to satisfy everyone. And it is also at this point that the discussion turns to a spiritual or a religious one. So I will end this here. If anyone would like my opinions on this matter any further, feel free to PM.
